As the first half wore on, the United States slowly gained more control of both the pace and the ball. But the same issue that marked its earlier qualifying missteps returned: It failed to convert its chances.
U.S. Coach Gregg Berhalter has relied on a rotation of players, particularly at forward, as he has chased both balance and goals in World Cup qualifying. On Sunday, he started Gyasi Zardes at striker over Jesús Ferreira, the surprise starter in Thursday’s win over El Salvador, and Ricardo Pepi, the teenager whose form may be the key to America’s World Cup hopes. Called upon again by Berhalter on Sunday, Zardes looked overmatched at times, and eventually was replaced in the 67th minute. Pepi offered a spark, but by then Canada had hunkered down to close out its victory.
Zardes, though, was not the only American who failed to convert his chances. In the 36th minute, Christian Pulisic sailed a free kick from just beyond the penalty area over the goal.