He won his second Cy Young in 2019, and hints of star status appeared. Not to be lost among smokeless tobacco tins in his locker were two cards on a shelf, both from the New York Police Department’s Lieutenants Benevolent Association. In the bottom right corner of each card, a yellow label is where the recipient’s name is typed in black. On one, he was Jacob deGrom. On the other, he was recognized by his rank in the game: Cy Young.
Upon returning to Florida, a tradition unchanged by his fame, deGrom lowered the velocity in Volusia County, ordered the best-selling hillbilly sandwich with pulled pork from the local haunt and fished in honey holes. His son, Jaxon, is 5; his daughter, Aniston, is 3. When he doesn’t understand a popular-culture reference, he says, “Two kids, too busy,” and real estate occupies a portion of his time as well. He purchased what he called “quite a bit of acreage” in his hometown and talked about building a “forever house” on what once was an orange grove bordered by a few lakes and dotted with a pond.
“His comfort is out in the middle of the woods with a select handful of people around him,” said Aaron Crittenden, who played with deGrom at Stetson. “He can be perfectly content living out his days doing just that.”
Uncertainty will accompany him home this time. When he wasn’t on the mound this season, he was in a magnetic resonance imaging machine seeking answers for a string of injuries that ranged from soreness to inflammation. Though Sandy Alderson, the president of the Mets, insisted in September that the ulnar collateral ligament in deGrom’s right elbow was “perfectly intact,” the pitcher was officially shut down for the season this week. Relegated to shagging balls most days, he occasionally threw left-handed to keep his mind occupied.